5 Reasons to Rethink Installing a Walk- In Tub for Aging in Place

As we age, making our homes safer and more accessible becomes a priority. Walk-in tubs are often marketed as a perfect solution for seniors, but they may not always be the best choice. Here are five reasons you might want to reconsider installing a walk-in tub in your home:

1. High Installation Costs and Higher Utility Costs

Walk-in tubs can be quite expensive to purchase and install. This significant investment might not be feasible for everyone, especially when there are other, more affordable modifications that can enhance bathroom safety. In addition to the costs of the basic tub, a larger water heater tank is needed - recommendation is a 75-80 gallon tank. Most existing residences have 50 gallon tanks. It takes approximately 55 gallons to fill a walk-in tub and most existing homes don't have that capacity to fill a tub. One fill will drain the tank and the resident will not have hot water until the tank can refill adding to the overall utility costs for a homeowner.

2. Long Fill and Drain Times

One of the common complaints about walk-in tubs is the time it takes to fill and drain them. Users must sit inside the tub while it fills and drains, which can be uncomfortable and time-consuming. This can be particularly problematic for those with limited patience or who are sensitive to temperature changes. One of the reasons for long fill times is that the existing plumbing lines in residential homes are usually 1/2" inch pipes and it is recommended that the plumbing have at least a 3/4" in pipes to allow for the filling of walk-in tubs.

3. Potential for Water Damage

Improper installation or a faulty seal on the door can lead to water leaks, causing damage to your bathroom floor and surrounding areas. This risk of water damage can result in costly repairs and maintenance, negating some of the benefits of having a walk-in tub.

4. Limited Mobility Benefits

While walk-in tubs are designed to be accessible, they may not be suitable for everyone with mobility issues. For instance, individuals who use wheelchairs might find it challenging to transfer in and out of the tub. In such cases, a roll-in shower with a bench might be a more practical and safer option.

5. Space Constraints

Walk-in tubs are larger than standard bathtubs and may not fit well in smaller bathrooms. The installation might require significant remodeling, which can be both disruptive and expensive. Because of the bigger tub footprint and the amount of water a tub will hold, the flooring underneath a tub will need to be reinforced to carry that load. Additionally, the larger size can make the bathroom feel cramped, reducing overall accessibility.

Conclusion

While walk-in tubs offer several benefits, including enhanced safety and comfort, they are not without their drawbacks. Before making a decision, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons and consider alternative solutions that might better suit your needs and budget. Consulting with a professional can help you make an informed choice that ensures your home remains a safe and comfortable place to age in place.

Do you have any specific concerns about walk-in tubs, or are you considering other home modifications for aging in place?